How to Reason Well [Oikeiôsis, Cardinal Virtues, and Role Ethics]
In the last episode I explained that, for the Stoics, a good human being is one who reasons well. In this one I cover something just as foundational to Stoic practice, which is Oikeiôsis, and that means also covering the Cardinal Virtues and Role Ethics.
Oikeiôsis can be partially described as a theory of psychological development. We start out concerned with ourselves, and as we grow that concern widens to parents and siblings, then friends and community, then country, humanity, and nature itself (what Hierocles would have called "circles of concern"). The Stoics pointed to the love parents naturally have for their children as the starting point of all our care for other people, and they said that as we mature, reason takes over the job instinct had been doing (they described reason as the craftsman of impulse). The early circles more or less take care of themselves, but the outer ones take active effort because they are distant, enormous, and full of people whose ideas may disgust us. I ask you to picture the supporters of the last political leader you really disliked, and then ask whether you want to care about how justly they are treated.
To know what reasoning well looks like, we have to understand Virtue. I go through the four Cardinal Virtues (Wisdom, Justice, Courage, and Temperance) and some of the subordinate virtues beneath each, and I explain the Unity of Virtues using a puzzle and a judge in the highest court of the land. Virtue cannot exist in partial measure, which is why there are no sages, why the pursuit takes a lifetime, and why it keeps Stoics humble. It is also why I say other people's moral errors come from poor reasoning and not from some supernatural evil, and why humanising people is harder than turning them into monsters. Good reasoning, then, looks like a choice that is wise, just, courageous, and temperate all at once, and we check our choices against those four virtues and against our roles.
That brings us to Role Ethics, and why using roles and duties doesn't turn Stoicism into a hybrid with Kantian Deontology (moral value comes from virtue, and roles are where that virtue gets practised). I walk through the four kinds of role, which are universal, circumstantial, individual, and elective, and explain why "blind person" counts as a role even though it isn't a job in the way you probably think of jobs. I also separate role friction, which is common, from true role conflict, which is rare, with the example of your house burning down the night before a work day and a boss who demands you come in anyway.
I finish by running one example through the whole thing, using that political supporter you'd prefer not to have round for tea. You find the circle they're in, you name your role in relation to them, and you let the virtues tell you how to fill that role well, and every time you do that you get a little better at reasoning well.
If you have questions, leave them in the comments or send them through the form on stoicismpod.com or tannerocampbell.com.
Learn about how you can work with me: https://tannerocampbell.com
Apply for an upcoming cohort: https://cohort.tannerocampbell.com
Join the community: https://skool.com/tannerocampbell
Mentioned in this episode:
Apple Podcasts
Spotify